- North Korea's Kim threatens to use nukes if attacked
- Taiwan cleans up after Typhoon Krathon batters south
- Bayern look to rebound at bogey side Frankfurt
- Finally beaten Madrid aiming for Villarreal rebound in La Liga
- Crude stable after Israel-Iran surge, Hong Kong stocks resume gains
- Bagnaia leads Martin in first Japan MotoGP practice
- Bolivia's Morales investigated for rape of a minor: minister
- Former Wallaby O'Connor signs for Canterbury Crusaders
- Ipswich Town's Luongo enticed back to Socceroos under new coach Popovic
- Three US police convicted in connection with beating death of Black man
- Iran's Khamenei to give rare Friday sermon after attack on Israel
- EU court set for key Diarra ruling which could shake up transfer market
- Taliban's battle with IS opens door to foreign cooperation
- More than AI misinformation, US voters worry about lying politicians
- EU states set to greenlight extra tariffs on EVs from China
- Could abortion hold the keys to the White House for Kamala Harris?
- Anti-Trump Republican Cheney rallies with Harris in key battleground
- Hera spacecraft to probe asteroid deflected by defence test
- AI bubble or 'revolution'? OpenAI's big payday fuels debate
- One job by day, another by night as US voters make ends meet
- Guatemala choses new Supreme Court judges in questioned process
- Man Utd's Ten Hag faces make-or-break trip to Aston Villa
- US dockworkers to head back to work after tentative deal
- Top Mexican court to examine contested judicial reforms
- Cuban music legend Omara Portuondo retires aged 93
- Melania Trump defends abortion, challenging husband's campaign
- Arc de Triomphe retains allure as the race where legends are made
- Garth Brooks accused of rape in new lawsuit
- Judge me at the end of the season, says under-fire Man Utd boss Ten Hag
- Source close to Hezbollah says Israel launches 11 consecutive strikes on south Beirut
- Civil society groups demand action against 'sexist' AI disinformation
- After Helene's destruction, North Carolina starts to rebuild
- Maguire spares Man Utd's blushes in Europe as Chelsea, Tottenham win
- Southeast US reels as storm Helene death toll hits 200
- Maguire saves Man Utd from more pain in Porto
- Dockers end three-day strike at Montreal port
- Canadian auto parts magnate faces more sexual assault charges
- What next for OpenAI after $157 billion bonanza?
- England's Skinns sets course record with 60 at PGA event
- Spurs creep past Ferencvaros in the Europa League
- Unbeaten NFL Vikings face Jets in London as Chiefs meet Saints
- FIFA defers decision on call to suspend Israel
- US seizes internet domains allegedly used by Russian hackers
- French jihadist linked to Charlie Hebdo attackers jailed for life
- Top Africa football boss facing Swiss probe over payments
- Pakistan down Sri Lanka at Women's T20 World Cup
- Bangladesh 'emotional' after first win in 10 years at Women's T20 World Cup
- Twice displaced: Syrian refugees flee home from Lebanon
- Mexico's new president unveils steps to boost women's rights
- Israel-Hamas war causes 86-percent dive in Gaza GDP: IMF
SCS | -1.98% | 12.62 | $ | |
NGG | -2.7% | 66.97 | $ | |
CMSC | -0.16% | 24.74 | $ | |
BCC | -0.9% | 138.29 | $ | |
RBGPF | 100% | 58.93 | $ | |
CMSD | -0.16% | 24.89 | $ | |
RIO | -1.42% | 69.83 | $ | |
GSK | -2.81% | 38.37 | $ | |
BCE | -1.77% | 33.84 | $ | |
RELX | -1.46% | 46.61 | $ | |
JRI | -0.6% | 13.3 | $ | |
AZN | -2.12% | 77.93 | $ | |
RYCEF | 1.15% | 6.98 | $ | |
VOD | -0.52% | 9.69 | $ | |
BP | 0.28% | 32.46 | $ | |
BTI | -2.45% | 35.11 | $ |
EU court set for key Diarra ruling which could shake up transfer market
An EU court will on Friday deliver its verdict in the case of former French footballer Lassana Diarra against FIFA, a potentially landmark decision which could shake up the football transfer system.
The court of justice of the European Union (CJEU) will decide whether a player can unilaterally terminate his contract, sparked by a dispute between Diarra and his former club Lokomotiv Moscow a decade ago.
"In a way, the Lassana Diarra affair is the Bosman 2.0 affair," said Diarra's Belgian lawyer Jean-Louis Dupont, who was also involved in the 1995 case of footballer Jean-Marc Bosman.
The Bosman ruling allowed players to move to another club at the end of their contract without a transfer fee being paid and also ended quotas on foreign players at clubs.
"If this judgement reflects the conclusions of the advocate general of the CJEU, the current FIFA transfer system will have come to an end," said Dupont, arguing that the rules which prevented Diarra from finding a new club "violate the free movement of workers".
Dupont pointed to the conclusions rendered on April 30 by the court's top legal advisor, Maciej Szpunar, according to whom FIFA rules "limiting the ability of clubs to recruit" would be contrary to the principle of free competition within the EU.
Other legal experts familiar with the case are more measured and do not foresee a "Lassana Diarra judgement" of the magnitude of the Bosman ruling which revolutionised the transfer market in Europe.
The Diarra saga goes back 10 years.
In August 2014, Lokomotiv terminated the midfielder's contract citing contractual breaches by the player. The Russian club also sought 20 million euros ($22m) compensation from Diarra.
Diarra, now 39, refused and requested that Lokomotiv pay him compensation.
He was eventually ordered to pay his former club 10 million euros by FIFA, a fine that was upheld by the Court of Arbitration for Sport. Diarra also received a backdated 15-month suspension.
- Legally trapped -
According to FIFA regulations, if a player terminates his contract unilaterally and "without just cause", he must pay compensation which includes his remuneration and benefits until the end of his contract.
And a purchasing club could be affected by compensation.
For his part, Diarra requested six million euros from world football governing body FIFA, on the grounds that its transfer rules had prevented him from playing during most of the 2014-2015 season.
As a result of the dispute clubs were not rushing to recruit Diarra. Belgian side Charleroi rescinded their contract offer, afraid of the possible legal and financial consequences.
The former France international, who went on to join Marseille in 2015, decided to take the matter to court, supported by the global players' union, FIFPro.
After several twists and turns, the Belgian court, whose jurisdiction FIFA contested, asked a so-called "preliminary" question to the CJEU in 2022.
In essence the question was -- are the regulations on the status and transfer of players compatible with EU competition law and free movement?
According to advocate general Szpunar, the provisions applied by FIFA "are likely to discourage and dissuade clubs from hiring the player for fear of a financial risk".
"Limiting the ability of clubs to recruit players necessarily affects competition between clubs on the market for the acquisition of professional players," the Polish lawyer argued.
If the CJEU were to follow this line of argument, players could leave their club without fear of being legally trapped afterwards.
Capped 34 times by France, Diarra also played for Chelsea, Arsenal, Portsmouth and Real Madrid before ending his career at Paris Saint-Germain in 2019.
V.Dantas--PC