- 'Evacuate now, now, now': Florida braces for next hurricane
- Sparks fly as Orban berates EU 'elites' in parliament trip
- US finalizes rule to remove lead pipes within a decade
- Solanke hungry for second England cap after seven-year wait
- Gilded canopy restored at Vatican basilica
- Zverev scrapes through, Djokovic cruises to Shanghai Masters last 16
- Trump secretly sent Covid tests to Putin: Bob Woodward book
- Gauff answers critics: 'It's hard to win all the time'
- Neural networks, machine learning? Nobel-winning AI science explained
- China says raised 'serious concerns' with US over trade curbs
- Boeing delivers 27 MAX jets in September despite strike
- Italy seek Nations League consistency as Germany continue rebuild
- From boom to budgeting as reality bites for Saudi football
- US trade gap narrowest in five months as imports slip
- Stay and 'you are going to die': Florida braces for next hurricane
- England 96-1 after Salman's century lifts Pakistan to 556
- Hollywood star Idris Elba champions African cinema in Ghana
- Djokovic rolls Cobolli to make Shanghai Masters last 16
- Milan's Hernandez receives two-game suspension after referee rant
- Geoffrey Hinton, soft-spoken godfather of AI
- Ex-Barcelona and Spain great Iniesta retires aged 40
- Ex-skipper Skelton eyes Wallabies November return
- Spanish great Iniesta leaves indelible legacy after retirement
- Indian Kashmir elects first regional government in a decade
- Duo wins Physics Nobel for key breakthroughs in AI
- September second-warmest on record: EU climate monitor
- Pastor wanted by US for sex trafficking to run for Philippine senate
- Mozambican writer Mia Couto dreams future leaders set an 'example'
- German 'Maddie' suspect could be free soon after cleared of separate sex crimes
- China says to take anti-dumping measures against EU brandy imports
- German suspect in 'Maddie' case cleared in separate sex crimes trial
- Israel expands offensive against Hezbollah in south Lebanon
- Bangladesh's Yunus says no elections before reforms
- England strike twice as Pakistan reach 397-6 at lunch in first Test
- Taiwan's Foxconn says building world's largest 'superchip' plant
- Kenya's deputy president faces impeachment vote
- N. Korean soldiers 'highly likely' killed in Ukraine: Seoul
- 'Appeals Centre' to referee EU social media disputes
- US Supreme Court to hear 'ghost guns' regulation case
- 'Small' oil leaks detected in Samoa after NZ navy shipwreck
- Nobel literature jury may go for non-Western writer
- At Istanbul church, blessed spring offers hope to Christians and Muslims
- From Bolivia to Indonesia, deforestation continues apace
- Myanmar to send rep to regional summit for first time in three years
- Prabowo set to lead bolder Indonesia on world stage
- Tampa zoo rushes Chompers the porcupine and others to safety as Milton nears
- New Japan PM to hold talks on ASEAN sidelines
- Record number of climbers chase 14-peak dream in Tibet
- Former South Korea clinic for US 'comfort women' to be demolished
- Chiefs battle past Saints to stay unbeaten
CMSC | -0.06% | 24.555 | $ | |
RBGPF | -0.46% | 60.52 | $ | |
CMSD | 0.55% | 24.926 | $ | |
SCS | -0.19% | 12.925 | $ | |
BTI | -0.16% | 35.145 | $ | |
NGG | 0.57% | 65.855 | $ | |
AZN | -0.29% | 76.65 | $ | |
RIO | -4.77% | 66.45 | $ | |
GSK | -1.54% | 38.045 | $ | |
RYCEF | 1.29% | 6.97 | $ | |
RELX | 1.02% | 46.515 | $ | |
VOD | -0.26% | 9.665 | $ | |
BCE | -0.8% | 33.265 | $ | |
BCC | -0.03% | 141.23 | $ | |
JRI | 0.2% | 13.206 | $ | |
BP | -3.75% | 31.942 | $ |
US judge grills both sides in landmark Google antitrust trial
A US judge on Thursday pushed against the central pleas of both US government and Google lawyers as he heard their closing arguments at a landmark antitrust trial in Washington.
Federal Judge Amit Mehta, whose decision is not expected until later in the year, raised his questions during two days of hearings that come six months after the conclusion of testimony.
The case is the first of five major lawsuits by the US government to reach trial, with Meta, Amazon, Apple and a separate case against Google also heading for federal court.
The trial is the first time the US Department of Justice (DOJ) has faced a big tech company in court since Microsoft was targeted more than two decades ago over the dominance of its Windows operating system.
The decision in the search engine case will be made by Judge Mehta, who presided over several months of testimony that saw Google CEO Sundar Pichai and other top executives take the stand.
At the heart of the government's case is the massive payments made by Google to Apple and other companies to keep its world-leading search engine as the default on iPhones, web browsers and other products.
The trial revealed payments reaching tens of billions of dollars every year for Google to keep its prime real estate on Apple hardware or the Safari and Mozilla browsers.
In 2022, Google paid Apple $20 billion for the default status, trial documents unsealed this week showed.
DOJ lawyers allege that Google achieved and perpetuated its dominance -- and strangled rivals -- through these default deals that also expanded to Samsung and other device makers.
But Judge Mehta expressed doubts that the case had sufficiently demonstrated the negative consequences necessary to deem the deals anti-competitive according to US law and precedent.
The key precedent is the landmark Microsoft case, which helped define how a tech platform can illegally abuse its monopoly to punish rivals.
But Mehta inferred that the Google case was very different from Microsoft's as it did not involve agreements to outright exclude competing browsers and other products.
"This case is different" because the user of an iPhone has the option to download and use rival apps, Mehta said.
"You have to show actual anti-competitive effects. You have to establish foreclosure first and if you can't, you lose," Mehta told the US government lawyers.
- Billions to Apple -
Mehta also poked holes in Google's defense, wondering how any rival search engine with a similar quality product could win access to the default deals if the cost would require tens of billions of dollars.
"Even if they can meet on that (quality) battlefield, they then would have to spend billions more to make Apple whole," Mehta said.
Mehta also focused questions on whether search queries on Amazon, Facebook or Expedia competed with Google, as argued by the tech giant.
Including activity on those websites would damage the US case, which rests on maintaining that general search, in which Google has over 80 percent of the US market share, is the relevant market.
Mehta also homed in on Google's contention that DuckDuckGo, the privacy focused search engine, was a competitor.
"You really think that DuckDuckGo is a competitor on Google?" Mehta asked Google's lawyer, who insisted that it was.
Lawyers from the Justice Department also faced pointed questions, with Mehta rejecting the idea that Google's dominance has stifled innovation for search.
That would be "a hard road for you to go down", the judge warned.
X.Matos--PC